|
How can I trust the Marketing Choice surveys when there seems to be leading questions?
Why doesn’t the Alberta government rely on the CWB election process to bring about change?
How will farmer returns be affected if single desk marketing for wheat and barley is eliminated?
Doesn’t the CWB works to maximize returns to farmers?
Can I still market my grain through the Canadian Wheat Board if a test market is established in Alberta?
Would a 10-year test market allow farmers complete freedom of choice?
What about the small farmers who may not have a lot of grain to sell and don't follow the markets?
How will Alberta be able to uphold the reputation of Canadian grain in world markets?
How can I trust the Marketing Choice surveys when there seems to be leading questions?
Many surveys are done by different groups. The Ipsos Reid Marketing Choice surveys (Fall 2003 and February 2005) that have shown significant farmer support for Marketing Choice, are the only ones that have been used by the Alberta Government. The questions on these surveys are not leading and everyone may see them. Both are found on this website under the Marketing Choice section - Have a look! Any other surveys that you may have answered regarding Marketing Choice are not commissioned by the Alberta Government, and the statistics are not used by Choice Matters.
Return to top
Why doesn’t the Alberta government rely on the CWB election process to bring about change?
The Alberta government respects the fact that two-thirds of the CWB Board of Directors is elected. The Alberta government respects the fact that two-thirds of the CWB Board of Directors is elected. It is important to note, however, that only one of the ten districts lies wholly within Alberta's borders.
The Government of Alberta is elected as well, and has a responsibility to act on behalf of its constituents – all Albertans. Repeated polls have shown that the majority of Alberta’s farmers would prefer marketing choice, a reality not reflected by the CWB’s electoral process.
The Government of Alberta encourages all eligible farmers to vote in the CWB elections. The purpose of the Choice Matters campaign is to ensure all farmers have all the information they need to make informed decisions about the future of the grain marketing system in Alberta. The sharing of information on all sides of a debate is a responsible way to promote democracy.
Return to top
How will farmer returns be affected if single desk marketing for wheat and barley is eliminated?
Alberta is proposing the test open market in order to move towards a more prosperous, sustainable farm and agri-industry sector.
Farmer returns are primarily based on the global marketplace. Dividing the small Canadian portion of that global market into CWB-bought grain and open-market grain will not have an adverse effect on world market prices.
Alberta’s producers successfully market other grains on the open market. Marketing choice would allow them to do the same for wheat and barley designated for export and human consumption.
Return to top
Doesn’t the CWB works to maximize returns to farmers?
No. Only individual farmers know what is best for them in terms of maximizing their returns.
The CWB cannot and does not maximize returns to all farmers. That would suggest picking the highest price day of the year and selling all wheat/barley through the locations/customers that provide the best returns to customers. The CWB may attempt to maximize sales price levels, but it does not necessarily attempt to maximize volumes.
Alberta supports individual initiative and individual risk and reward. The CWB does not know – nor could it know – each individual farmer’s needs in terms of cash flows, fixed costs, break-even points, etc. For example, a good sale for one farmer (early movement, early cash payment) may not be acceptable to another (one who can afford to hold his grain until spring in anticipation of higher prices).
Return to top
Can I still market my grain through the Canadian Wheat Board if a test market is established in Alberta?
A test market would not abolish the farmer’s choice to sell through the Canadian Wheat Board. It would simply allow alternatives to operate next to it.
Return to top
Would a 10-year test market allow farmers complete freedom of choice?
The vision for the future is to have a wide open market for farmers to sell their grain wherever they want.
Return to top
What about the small farmers who may not have a lot of grain to sell and don't follow the markets?
These farmers would also have choices. They can sell to the CWB or sell directly into a market if they choose to do so.
Return to top
How will Alberta be able to uphold the reputation of Canadian grain in world markets?
While the CWB takes credit for branding western Canadian wheat and barley as high-quality, the Canadian Grain Commission and the grain trade play a much more significant role in maintaining Canada’s reputation than the marketing agency. The CWB does not, on its own, guarantee quality; rather, it relies on the other agencies in the system to ensure the grain meets contract specifications. Moreover, the non-CWB markets (canola, flax, peas, etc) also enjoy an excellent reputation for high quality on world markets – without the CWB’s involvement. In an Alberta test open market, nothing will need to change to maintain Canada’s reputation for high-quality grain. Grading would remain the same as it is now. A more direct relationship and the resulting accountability may make it easier to enter into more of an identity preserved market system and thus create more value for both the grain handler and farmer.
Return to top
|